Mutual Funds Vs Managed Accounts

There are some major differences in costs andwhen the markets are down, and selling when
efficiency between mutual funds and managedthings are expensive, ie. when markets are up.
accounts that may have a meaningful effect onUnfortunately, most fund managers are forced to
your investment returns.do the exact opposite because of a phenomenon
Mutual funds are pooled funds, meaning all theknows as the Small Investor Effect. The
money that you and thousands of other investorstheory-and proven fact-is that the typical investor
send to the fund company will be put into onebuys funds when the markets are doing well and
large pool of money and the manager will managesells when they are not. The Fear & Greed
this pool. If an investor wants to add new moneyeffect in action. That would be OK to us except
or take out some money, it goes into and comesthat this activity puts the fund manager in a bind
out of this pool. A managed account on the otherand forces him to sell when the markets are a
hand is a private account, meaning that you havebuy and buy when the markets are a sell,
your own separate account which is noteffecting us all as shareholders. Separate or
commingled with other accounts.managed accounts were invented partly for this
There are three main cost components in areason and in theory, they avoid this serious drag
mutual fund:on performance-as long as we trust the manager
1) internal expense ratio-the incidental day-to-dayto do his thing and not interfere with our own
expenses of the fund like the utility bills, rent,fear and greed impulses.
salaries, research etc.,Most of the time, managed accounts are the way
2) marketing, loads and 12b-1 fees that areto go if you meet the minimums required,
incurred in marketing the funds andtypically $50,000 to $100,000. Many mutual fund
3) transaction costs. These typically add up tomanagers also have their brand private or
anywhere from 1% to 3% or more annually formanaged accounts. There are times however,
any mutual fund, even so-called "no load" funds. Awhen a mutual fund is the right choice. A 401k
great resource is John Bogle's definitive bible calledplan or an IRA where you are adding fixed
Bogle on Mutual Funds.amounts periodically would be a good example
Managed funds typically can be had for 1% to 2%because you cannot do that efficiently in a
all-in if you can show your broker that you knowmanaged account.
the ropes. Much less if your accounts go into theDISCLAIMER: I have presented information that I
7 figures. With mutual funds, you are stuck withbelieve to be true but do not vouch for the
the common expense ratios no matter howaccuracy of any of it. Please use this article only
much money you invest.as a starting point for further inquiry if you think
The most crucial difference to me is thethere is some merit in doing so, then do your
efficiency factor however. If you picture yourselfown due diligence and consult with your qualified
as the manager of a fund, you will be looking atadvisors before you invest.
valuations and buying when things are cheap, ie.